A 1035 exchange is a provision in the IRS tax code (Internal Revenue Code Section 1035) that lets you move money from an existing non-qualified annuity, life insurance policy or endowment contract into a new eligible policy without paying immediate income tax on your gains.
Cashing out your old contract triggers ordinary income tax on every dollar of gain, plus a 10% IRS penalty if you are under age 59½. A 1035 exchange avoids that by moving your full account value and original cost basis directly from your old insurance company to your new one. Your gains stay tax-deferred until you take withdrawals from the new contract.
Key takeaways
- Tax-free swap for non-qualified policies: Section 1035 applies to non-qualified contracts (bought with after-tax money). IRAs and 401(k)s use tax-free rollovers or trustee-to-trustee transfers instead.
- Direction is one-way: you can exchange life insurance → annuity or annuity → annuity, and either one into a qualified long-term care (LTC) policy. You can never exchange an annuity for a life insurance policy.
- Direct carrier-to-carrier transfer only: you cannot touch the money. There is no 60-day rollover window for a 1035 exchange. If your old insurer mails a check made out to you, the IRS taxes your gains immediately.
- Tax-free doesn’t mean fee-free: the IRS won’t tax a valid 1035 exchange, but your current carrier can still charge a surrender fee or Market Value Adjustment (MVA) if your contract is still inside its surrender period.
Have an existing annuity or life policy? Use our 1035 exchange break-even calculator to see how many months a higher rate takes to recover your surrender charge.
What a 1035 Exchange Is in Plain English
When you buy a non-qualified annuity with after-tax savings, your interest or investment earnings grow tax-deferred. If you surrender (cancel) that annuity to buy a better one, the IRS treats your withdrawal on a Last-In, First-Out (LIFO) basis. Every dollar of profit comes out first and is taxed as ordinary income in that calendar year.
Example of why Section 1035 matters: suppose you put $100,000 into a deferred annuity seven years ago, and it has grown to $140,000 ($100,000 cost basis + $40,000 gain).
- If you cash out to buy a new annuity: you owe ordinary income tax on the $40,000 gain right away. At a 24% federal and 5% state tax bracket, you lose $11,600 to taxes (and another $4,000 if you’re under 59½). That leaves only $128,400 to reinvest.
- If you use a 1035 exchange: your full $140,000 transfers directly to the new annuity carrier with $0 tax due today. All $140,000 earns interest at your new rate, and your original $100,000 cost basis carries over to the new policy.
1035 Exchange vs. IRA Rollover vs. 1031 Exchange
People often confuse a 1035 exchange with two other tax rules. Here is how they differ.
| Feature | 1035 Exchange (IRC § 1035) | IRA / 401(k) Transfer or Rollover | 1031 Exchange (IRC § 1031) |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it covers | Non-qualified annuities, life insurance, endowments and qualified LTC policies | Qualified retirement accounts (Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, 401(k), 403(b)) | Investment or business real estate |
| Tax status of money | Funded with after-tax dollars (cost basis + tax-deferred gains) | Funded with pre-tax (or Roth) retirement dollars | Real property with capital gains |
| 60-day check rule? | No. Funds must transfer directly between insurers. Touching the check triggers tax. | Yes (once per 12 months for indirect IRA rollovers, though a direct transfer is safer) | No. Requires a Qualified Intermediary and 45/180-day deadlines. |
| Tax form issued | Form 1099-R (Box 7 Code 6 = tax-free exchange) | Form 1099-R (Box 7 Code G = direct rollover) or a non-reportable trustee transfer | Form 8824 (Like-Kind Exchanges) |
What Can Be Exchanged for What (The IRS Directional Rules)
Section 1035 only permits transfers that keep your gains inside the income-tax system, or move them toward retirement income or long-term care. You can never move into a contract that erases income tax through a tax-free death benefit.
Since the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (PPA) took effect in 2010, there are four policy types in the 1035 matrix.
| Existing policy you own (from) | → New life insurance policy | → New non-qualified annuity | → New endowment contract | → Qualified long-term care (LTC) policy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life insurance policy (Whole, Universal, Variable, Variable Universal) | YES (tax-free) | YES (tax-free) | YES (tax-free) | YES (tax-free) |
| Non-qualified annuity (MYGA, fixed, FIA, variable, immediate) | NO, never allowed | YES (tax-free) | NO | YES (tax-free) |
| Endowment contract | NO | YES (tax-free) | YES (tax-free, if income begins no later than the original) | YES (tax-free) |
| Qualified long-term care (LTC) policy | NO | NO | NO | YES (tax-free) |
Why Can’t You Exchange an Annuity for Life Insurance?
Life insurance death benefits pass to beneficiaries income-tax-free under IRC Section 101(a). Annuity gains, by contrast, are always taxed as ordinary income at some point, either to you or to your beneficiaries. If the IRS allowed an annuity-to-life swap, you could permanently erase the income tax owed on decades of annuity gains, so annuity → life insurance is prohibited.
Popular Real-World 1035 Swaps
- Old fixed annuity or MYGA → higher-rate MYGA: your surrender period ended on a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) that now renews at a low rate. You swap it into a new MYGA paying today’s top fixed annuity rates.
- High-fee variable annuity → low-cost fixed or indexed annuity: you own a variable annuity charging 2.50% to 3.50% a year in mortality and expense (M&E), subaccount and rider fees. You want principal protection with no annual fee drag.
- Deferred annuity → immediate income annuity (SPIA): you finished growing your nest egg and want a guaranteed lifetime paycheck. You exchange the balance into a single premium immediate annuity (SPIA), which also gets a favorable tax exclusion ratio.
- Unneeded cash-value life insurance → annuity: your children are grown and you no longer need a costly whole life or universal life death benefit. A 1035 exchange moves the cash surrender value into an annuity. If the policy is “underwater” (you paid $90,000 in premiums but the cash value is only $65,000), your full $90,000 cost basis carries over, so the next $25,000 of annuity growth is tax-free.
- Annuity → hybrid annuity/long-term care policy: thanks to the Pension Protection Act, you can move an old annuity with large embedded gains into a PPA-compliant long-term care annuity. If you later use the funds for qualified long-term care expenses, even the embedded gains come out tax-free.
1035 Exchange Rules: Same Owner, Direct Transfer, Cost Basis and Partial Exchanges
To keep your transaction tax-free under IRC Section 1035, the IRS enforces the rules below. Breaking any one of them can turn a routine transfer into an immediate taxable withdrawal.
1. The Same Owner and Same Annuitant (Insured) Rule
The owner and annuitant (or insured person on a life policy) on the new contract must match the old contract at the moment of the exchange.
- No new owners: you cannot 1035 exchange an annuity owned by you into an annuity owned by your child.
- No adding a joint owner mid-transfer: you cannot turn a single-owner policy into a joint-owner policy during the 1035 transfer. Complete the exchange first and update beneficiaries afterward, or talk to a CPA before changing ownership.
- Exceptions: if one spouse on a joint-life policy has died, the surviving insured spouse can exchange into a single-life policy. Transfers between spouses incident to divorce fall under IRC Section 1041.
2. Direct Carrier-to-Carrier Transfer (Never Touch the Funds)
Your old insurance company must send the funds directly to the new insurance company after you sign an absolute assignment / 1035 exchange form.
- No 60-day window: there is no 60-day rollover rule for non-qualified annuities.
- A check to you is a surrender: if your insurer mails you a check, the IRS treats it as a taxable surrender followed by a new purchase. That holds even if you endorse the check to the new annuity company the next day.
3. Carryover Cost Basis (Your Tax History Travels With You)
A 1035 exchange defers taxes; it does not erase them. Your new annuity inherits the exact annuity cost basis from your old contract (your after-tax principal, minus any prior tax-free return of basis).
- Example: you bought Policy A with $100,000 and it grew to $150,000. You exchange into Policy B, which grows to $190,000. Policy B’s cost basis is still $100,000, and its taxable gain is $90,000 ($50,000 from Policy A + $40,000 from Policy B).
- Surrender clock note: your cost basis transfers over, but the new contract starts its own surrender schedule with the new insurer.
4. No Outstanding Policy Loans (“Boot” Trigger)
If your permanent life insurance policy or annuity has an outstanding loan, handle it before you start a 1035 exchange.
- Few carriers accept loans: most receiving annuity carriers will not take a policy with an existing loan.
- A netted-out loan is taxable: if the old carrier deducts your loan from the cash value before sending the rest, the IRS treats the paid-off loan as “boot” (cash received by you). It is taxable as ordinary income up to the total gain in your contract.
- Solution: if your policy has a gain, pay off the loan with outside cash before the exchange. For a life-to-life exchange, look for a carrier that will carry the loan over.
5. Partial 1035 Exchanges and the 180-Day Rule (Rev. Proc. 2011-38)
You don’t have to move your whole annuity balance. In a partial 1035 exchange, you move part of an existing annuity into a new annuity, for example to split one large annuity between two carriers.
- Pro-rata basis split: your cost basis and your gains split proportionally between the old and new contracts. Move 50% of the account value, and 50% of the basis and 50% of the gain go with it.
- The 180-day rule: under IRS Revenue Procedure 2011-38, you cannot take a withdrawal from either the old or the new contract within 180 days of the partial exchange.
- Breaking the 180-day rule: a withdrawal inside that window lets the IRS disqualify the partial exchange, or treat both contracts as one so gains are taxed first.
- The exception: the 180-day limit does not apply if the new contract is annuitized for your lifetime or for a guaranteed period of 10 years or more.
6. Consolidating Multiple Annuities Into One
Section 1035 also works in reverse. You can exchange two or three older non-qualified annuities, even from different insurers, into a single new annuity contract, as long as you are the same owner and annuitant on all of them. The new carrier holds the funds until the last check arrives, then issues one policy with a combined cost basis.
Step-by-Step Process, Forms and Timeline
A 1035 exchange needs two insurance companies to coordinate, and your current carrier has no reason to hurry your money out the door. Knowing the exact steps keeps your transfer from stalling.
Step 1: Audit Your Current Contract Before You Apply
Call your current carrier (or have our team set up a three-way call) and ask for these five numbers in writing:
- Current accumulation value vs. cash surrender value
- Remaining surrender charge percentage and its exact expiration date
- Current Market Value Adjustment (MVA), positive or negative, in dollars today
- Cost basis on file (your original after-tax investment)
- Active riders or minimum guaranteed rates you would give up by leaving
Step 2: Shop and Select Your New Annuity
Compare rates and carriers in the My Annuity Store Rate Marketplace or with our annuity calculators. Confirm the new carrier offers a 45-to-60-day rate lock on 1035 exchanges. A rate lock means that if rates drop while your old insurer processes the transfer, you still get the rate that was live the day you signed.
Lock in today's MYGA rate before it moves
Your rate is set by your application date, not the day rates change. Request a quote and we will confirm current rates for your state and premium, in writing, so you can decide before the market moves.
Step 3: Complete the Application, 1035 Assignment and Replacement Forms
You never request the money from your old insurer yourself. Instead, you submit your new annuity application to the new insurance company with two required documents:
- 1035 exchange / absolute assignment form: usually two pages. You assign your old contract to the new carrier and authorize it to request the funds directly. It asks for your current insurer’s name, address, phone number and policy number, and whether your policy is attached or marked “Lost Policy.”
- State replacement form and suitability comparison: every state requires a replacement notice when a new annuity is funded from an existing policy. It compares the old and new contracts side by side (rates, surrender charges, fees and riders) so reviewers can confirm the swap helps you.
Step 4: Carrier-to-Carrier Transfer and Conservation Period (Weeks 1 to 5)
Once your application passes suitability review at the new carrier:
- Days 1 to 3: the new insurer sends the 1035 request to your old insurer, by DTCC electronic transfer if both carriers participate, or by overnight mail or fax.
- Days 4 to 15 (the conservation window): your old carrier tells you (and your original agent) that a replacement was requested. Many insurers hold the request 5 to 10 business days to try to keep your business.
- Days 15 to 35: the old insurer closes the contract and sends the funds directly to the new insurer with a cost basis statement.
- Days 35 to 45: the new insurer receives the funds, applies your locked-in rate and issues your new annuity contract.
Tip to speed up your transfer by 7 to 14 days: ask whether your old carrier requires a Medallion Signature Guarantee or notarized signature on larger transfers. Also ask whether it needs the paper policy back, or will accept the “Lost Policy Certification” box on the 1035 form. Settling those two items up front prevents the most common rejected 1035 requests.
Step 5: Tax Reporting at Year-End (IRS Form 1099-R)
The following January, your old insurance company will mail you IRS Form 1099-R. Receiving a 1099-R does not mean you owe taxes.
- Box 1 (gross distribution): the total amount transferred to the new insurer.
- Box 2a (taxable amount): should read $0.00.
- Box 5 (employee contributions / insurance premiums): your cost basis that moved to the new carrier.
- Box 7 (distribution code): must show Code 6, which tells the IRS this was a tax-free Section 1035 exchange. You report it on your return, with $0 added to your taxable income.
Surrender Charges, MVAs and Rider Loss: When NOT to Exchange
A tax-free 1035 exchange is not automatically a smart move. Before you swap annuities, check three friction costs: surrender charges, Market Value Adjustments (MVAs) and riders you would give up.
How to Run the Break-Even Math (Worked Dollar Example)
Suppose you own a $100,000 non-qualified annuity (cost basis $80,000) crediting 3.00% a year. It has 1 year left on its surrender schedule with a 2.00% surrender charge ($2,000) and no MVA. You compare staying put with a 1035 exchange into a hypothetical 5-year MYGA paying 5.25%.
| Metric | Option A: Keep old annuity (3.00%) | Option B: 1035 exchange to 5.25% MYGA (after 2% surrender fee) | Option C: Cash out, pay 24% tax on gain, reinvest at 5.25% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting principal working for you | $100,000 | $98,000 ($100,000 minus the $2,000 surrender fee) | $93,680 ($98,000 minus $4,320 tax on the $18,000 net gain) |
| Annual guaranteed rate | 3.00% | 5.25% | 5.25% |
| Year 1 value | $103,000 | $103,145 (surrender fee recovered in month 11) | $98,598 |
| Year 3 value | $109,273 | $114,260 (+$4,987 ahead) | $109,223 |
| Year 5 value (end of term) | $115,927 | $126,572 (+$10,645 ahead of keeping the old policy) | $120,992 ($5,580 behind the 1035 exchange) |
Hypothetical example for illustration only. The 3.00% and 5.25% rates are not current quotes; see live rates in the My Annuity Store Rate Marketplace.
The break-even rule of thumb:
Break-even years ≈ (surrender charge % ± MVA %) ÷ (new rate % − old rate %)
- In the example above: paying a 2.00% surrender charge to gain 2.25% a year (5.25% minus 3.00%) breaks even in about 10.7 months (2.00 ÷ 2.25 = 0.89 years). Over the 5-year term, the swap leaves you $10,645 ahead.
- When to wait instead: if your remaining surrender charge is 7% and the rate gain is only 0.75%, break-even takes over 9 years. Wait until your surrender schedule ends.
1035 Exchange Break-Even Calculator
Enter your own numbers to see how long a higher rate takes to recover your surrender charge, and where you stand after the full term.
5 Red Flags: When You Should NOT Do a 1035 Exchange
- You would lose an “in-the-money” income rider (GLWB / GMIB). Many variable and fixed index annuities have a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit with an income base well above the cash surrender value. Say your cash value is $160,000 but your income base has grown to $240,000, guaranteeing $14,400 a year for life. Only the $160,000 cash value transfers; the extra $80,000 of income base disappears. Before you exchange, check what a new contract would pay on the lower balance with our income rider calculator.
- A negative MVA plus a surrender fee eats the gain. If rates have risen since you bought, an early exit can trigger a surrender charge and a negative MVA that cuts your transfer by another 2% to 5%. Always get a written net transfer quote from your current insurer first. If rates have fallen since you bought, a positive MVA can offset part of your surrender charge.
- You have a grandfathered high minimum guarantee (3% to 4% floor). Older annuities from the 1990s and early 2000s often guarantee 3.00% to 4.50% for life with no surrender charges left. Giving up a permanent, liquid 4% floor for a temporary rate bump is rarely worth locking up your money again.
- You can’t afford to reset the liquidity clock. Every new deferred annuity starts a fresh surrender period, usually 3 to 7 years. If you may need more than the 10% penalty-free withdrawal for a home, medical bill or business in the next few years, don’t lock your principal into a new schedule.
- An internal exchange with your current carrier is better. If your policy is still in its surrender period, ask whether your insurer offers a penalty-free internal 1035 exchange into a newer product. Also ask whether you can annuitize the existing policy without surrender fees.
Already own an annuity? Get a free annuity audit
Send us your most recent annuity statement and we will send back a written report on what the contract does, what it costs you, and whether a move would leave you better off after any surrender charge. No cost, and no obligation to change anything.
6 Common Mistakes That Trigger Unexpected Taxes
Even experienced owners break the tax-free status of a 1035 exchange with one of these six mistakes.
- Having the check made payable to you (“constructive receipt”). If you ask your old insurer to cancel your annuity and send you a check, the exchange is dead the moment they cut it. There is no 60-day grace period.
- Trying a “1035 exchange” on an IRA or Roth IRA annuity. Section 1035 only applies to non-qualified contracts. If your annuity sits inside a Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA or 403(b), the receiving carrier will reject 1035 paperwork. Qualified accounts use IRA direct transfer / direct rollover paperwork instead.
- Changing the owner or annuitant on the new application. Titling the new annuity to a living trust when the old one was owned individually, adding a non-spouse joint owner, or swapping spouses as owner can break the same-owner rule. Keep ownership identical on the 1035 paperwork, then make any allowed beneficiary or trust changes after the contract is issued.
- Taking a withdrawal within 180 days of a partial 1035 exchange. Say you exchange 50% of your annuity in March, then pull $10,000 from the old contract in June. Under Rev. Proc. 2011-38, that withdrawal can undo the tax treatment of the partial exchange, so check with a CPA before splitting a policy if you need cash soon.
- Exchanging a life insurance policy with an unpaid loan. Say your whole life policy has $150,000 of cash value, a $60,000 cost basis and a $50,000 loan, so it holds a $90,000 gain. If the old insurer nets out the loan and sends $100,000 to the new carrier, the IRS taxes you on $50,000 of ordinary income (“boot”) that year, even though no cash reached your bank account.
- Letting your rate lock expire over missing paperwork. Some insurers won’t release funds without the original policy or a signed Lost Policy Certification. Some also want a spousal consent signature in community-property states (AZ, CA, ID, LA, NV, NM, TX, WA, WI). Missing signatures can stall the transfer past the new carrier’s 45-to-60-day rate lock.
How My Annuity Store Helps You Decide (and Handles the Paperwork)
Before you sign a 1035 exchange form, confirm the swap puts more guaranteed dollars in your pocket after any surrender charges or MVAs. At My Annuity Store, our licensed team runs a side-by-side 1035 break-even analysis on your existing policy at no cost.
- We check your current policy: its exact surrender date, MVA, cost basis and any rider guarantees.
- We compare it with today’s rates: your contract against today’s highest fixed annuity rates from the 90+ top annuity companies on our platform.
- If staying put is smarter, we tell you to keep it.
- If exchanging makes sense, we do the paperwork: our new business team prepares the 1035 assignment and state replacement forms, locks your rate, and follows up with both insurers until your new policy is issued.
Ready to see if your current annuity can do better? Run the numbers with our annuity calculators, request a free annuity quote, or schedule a no-pressure call before you sign any 1035 exchange paperwork.
Frequently Asked Questions About the 1035 Exchange
What does a 1035 exchange do?
A 1035 exchange lets you replace an existing non-qualified annuity or life insurance policy with a new eligible contract without paying income tax on your gains at the time of the transfer. Your original cost basis and tax-deferred gains move directly into the new policy.
Can you do a 1035 exchange from an annuity to an IRA or Roth IRA?
No. You cannot move a non-qualified annuity (bought with after-tax dollars) into a Traditional IRA or Roth IRA with a 1035 exchange, because a 1035 exchange only moves money between non-qualified insurance contracts. If your annuity is already inside an IRA, you can move it to another IRA annuity tax-free with a direct IRA-to-IRA transfer.
How long does a 1035 exchange take?
Most 1035 exchanges take 2 to 6 weeks from the date you sign the new application until the new policy is issued. Carriers on the DTCC electronic system often finish in 10 to 15 business days, while mailed checks can take 30 to 45 days. Many receiving carriers lock your rate for 45 to 60 days while they wait for the funds.
How is a 1035 exchange reported on my tax return?
Your previous insurer mails IRS Form 1099-R in January for the year of the exchange. Box 1 shows the amount transferred, Box 2a shows a $0.00 taxable amount, Box 5 shows your transferred cost basis, and Box 7 shows distribution code 6 for a tax-free Section 1035 exchange. You report these figures on your Form 1040, with $0 tax owed.
Does a 1035 exchange reset the surrender period?
Yes. Your cost basis carries over from the old policy, but you are buying a new contract from the new insurer. The new policy starts its own surrender charge schedule, for example a 3-, 5- or 7-year term on a new MYGA.
Is there a limit on how many 1035 exchanges you can do?
The IRS places no limit on how often you can do a full 1035 exchange, unlike indirect IRA rollovers, which are limited to one every 12 months. However, state suitability rules prohibit “churning” (replacements that cost you surrender fees without a clear benefit), and the receiving insurer reviews every exchange.
Can I exchange a life insurance policy for an annuity tax-free?
Yes. Under IRC Section 1035, you can exchange a cash-value life insurance policy (whole life, universal life or variable universal life) for a non-qualified annuity tax-free, as long as the owner and insured/annuitant stay the same and any loans are handled. You can never go the other direction, from an annuity to life insurance.
Ready to Compare Your Annuity Options?
Talk with a licensed producer at no cost and compare rates from 90+ top annuity companies. No pressure, no obligation.
Prefer to talk on your schedule? Schedule a call
Editorial Disclosure: Our editorial team independently reviews and rates annuity products. My Annuity Store earns a commission from the insurance company if you purchase an annuity through our platform. There is no fee to you. This content is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Annuity products vary by state and carrier. Learn more.
