About Us

Kiara caudill sitting

Annuity Experts

Kiara Caudill founded My Annuity Store, Inc. in January 2020. My Annuity Store is located in Indianapolis, IN area but is licensed to sell annuities in 37 states.

Kiara spent the first 10 years of her career practicing as a clinical mental health therapist. It was during this time she learned that your financial health plays a tremendous role in your mental health.

Jason Caudill resigned from a Fortune 500 Company and joined his wife, Kiara, on July 1st, 2021. He spent 16 years in the annuity business in many roles including; college intern, marketing director, Vice President of Marketing for an Insurance Company, RVP for the largest independent Brokerage Firm in the U.S. and Director for a Division of Raymond James Private Client Group.



We only offer the Best Annuities (that are in your best interest).



Data-driven recommendations that are in your best interest.



Reveal the things other advisors don’t want you to know.

"A lack of educational materials and accessibility to structured products and annuities have hindered the widespread adoption of these strategies in the United States."

Jason Caudill, MBA

As Seen On:

we make annuities easy

Technology Driven

My Annuity Store, Inc. provides a platform for individuals to acquire knowledge, request, compare, price and select income, fixed, and fixed index annuities.

We aim to elevate and simplifying the experience of buying an annuity.

We specialize in retirement income planning and secure and safe retirement savings vehicles.

Our Process

Caudill family

Learn About Annuities

Decide if an Annuity is Right for you

Get Annuity Quotes

Buy an Annuity

Your Annuity Journey begins here

You’ve worked hard for your money! We’ll help you be sure it works just as hard for you.

What We are doing better

We offer fixed annuities and lifetime income annuities just like every other online annuity platform. What separates us from the rest is our specialization in fixed index annuities and LTC annuities.

Jason has wholesaled over $1 Billion in fixed index annuity contracts and is the self-proclaimed #1 Authority on Fixed Index Annuities.

Kiara caudill sitting

We know all things annuities so you don't have to

Schedule a free consultation to speak with Jason or Kiara to learn if an annuity may be right for you.

What Our Clients Say


With a fixed annuity, your deposited premium and all contract provisions are guaranteed by the issuing insurance company. For that reason, it is prudent to research the financial strength and ratings of the issuing company.

With fixed annuities, there are no fees, upfront loads or sales charges. 100% of your money goes into your contract without any expense to you. The only time you may incur a fee is if you choose to add an optional rider that comes with a cost.

Absolutely, that is something we do for our clients all of the time.

My Annuity Store is open Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM and Saturday from 8:30 AM to 12:30 PM Eastern Standard Time.

We are also available by appointment in the evenings.

Almost all annuities will pay your elected beneficiaries your full account value, without penalty, upon death.

We are located in Fishers, Indiana (20 minutes North of Indianapolis).

Our clients incur no fees, sales charges or upfront loads for our annuity shopping services. We  earn commissions paid to us directly from the insurance companies that we place business with.

All insurance products, including annuities, are regulated at the state rather than the federal level. Each state has a Life & Health Insurance Guaranty Association that backs fixed annuity products up to certain dollar limits. To find out the coverage in your state, visit our State Guaranty Associations page.

Recent Posts

Free Annuity Quote

Receive a personalized annuity quote within 4 business hours.