About Us

Kiara Caudill founded My Annuity Store, Inc. in January 2020. She spent the first 10 years of her career practicing as a clinical mental health therapist. It was during this time she learned that your financial health plays a large role in your mental health.

Her husband, Jason Caudill, joined My Annuity Store on July 1, 2021. He has been in the annuity industry for 15 years, serving in various roles including, Vice President of Marketing for Standard Life Insurance Company (now Guggenheim Life and Annuity), Regional Vice President for Ash Brokerage and Regional Director for Producers Choice Network (division of Raymond James Private Client Group).

Annuity & Retirement Planning Experts

Financial Advisors in Indianapolis, Indiana

Jason Caudill, MBA

President, Financial Advisor

Jason has an MBA in Entrepreneurship from Ball State University and a B.S. degree in Business Administration and Computer Information Systems from Ferris State University. He holds a Series 6 and Series 63 Securities License as well as a Life and Health Insurance License. 

He wholesaled over $1Billion in Annuity Contracts over his 15-year career.

Kiara Caudill

Founder & CEO

Kiara graduated from Goshen College with a B.A. Degree in Psychology with a minor in Anthropology/ Sociology in 2005. In 2007 Kiara graduated from Valparaiso University with an M.A. in Clinical Mental Health Counseling. She is also a licensed mental health therapist.

Kiara caudill my annuity store about picture


As Seen On:

Cbs logo
Nbc logo
Fox logo
The cw logo

#1 Authority on Fixed Index Annuities

Our solutions are designed to minimize risk, not increase it. Our nation is in an unprecedented situation with a population that grows older each day. As uncertainty persists and volatility creeps back up into the market, annuities products will likely continue to increase in popularity.

My Annuity Store, Inc. provides a platform for individuals to acquire knowledge, request, compare, price, and select income annuities, fixed annuities, and fixed index annuities. Our website is versatile, easy to use and is equipped with educational tools and annuity calculators aimed to help our visitors better understand the role annuities can play in a retirement portfolio. We believe a lack of educational materials and access to structured products and annuities has hindered the widespread adoption of these strategies in the United States.

My Annuity Store strives to educate and provide individuals with the materials and tools to better understand these products, so they feel comfortable utilizing them to achieve their overall investment goals.

feedback we love

What People Say About Us

Best option I found for learning about annuities after months of research. The team at My Annuity Store has done a wonderful job at providing easy to understand information on a complex topic. I will purchase my first annuity from them when ready.
Marcus krause
Marcus Krause
Great people to work with! The electronic application process was quick and easy. Would highly recommend there services to anyone!
Nathan rivers
Nathan RIvers

Financial Planning Blog

contact us

We are Here to Help You


10497 Balroyal Ct.,
Fishers, IN 46037


Free Consultation





Free Annuity Quote

Receive a personalized annuity quote within 4 business hours.