Fixed Index Annuity Pros and Cons

Because of that, annuities that initially might seem exactly alike can actually give you very different results.
Fixed Index Annuity Pros and Cons My Annuity Store, Inc. Hourglass with My Annuity Store Logo and a jar of cash sitting on a table.

Fixed Index Annuity Pros and Cons

Fixed index annuities, sometimes referred to as equity indexed annuities, have become increasingly popular in recent years. As a result, more annuity companies are now issuing index annuity contracts.

This has made it more difficult for consumers to decide which index annuity product is best for them.

In this guide, we’ll cover all of the fixed index annuity pros and cons in detail. I’ll also walk through the different features offered in a fixed index annuity and explain what options to look for based on your individual goals and objectives.

In this guide to the pros and cons of a fixed index annuity we’ll cover:

Like all major decisions in life, it is best to consider the pros and cons of a fixed index annuity prior to making any purchasing decisions. 

However, before evaluating any single specific annuity contract it’s best to have at least a working understanding of how indexed annuities work.

As such, before we compare and contrast index annuity pros and cons we’ll begin with what an indexed annuity is and how they work.

If you are already up to speed with fixed index annuities, you may prefer to jump directly to fixed index annuity pros and cons.

What is a Fixed Index Annuity?

Watch a Video: What is a fixed index annuity? (3 mins 51 seconds)

A primary benefit is you get upside potential when the market performs and your money is protected from a potential stock market crash. The trade-off is they don’t provide guaranteed annuity rates like many other annuity contracts.

One of the top indexed annuity pitfalls on our list of index annuity pros and cons is they do not provide you a guaranteed annuity rate like a multi year guaranteed annuity contract does.

On the flip side, of the many annuity contracts index annuities provide the best possible annuity growth of any fixed annuity type.

In fact, an indexed annuity has the most upside potential of all retirement investment options offering principal protection.

The below chart illustrates where they fall on the investment continuum.

Investment continuum chart showing where an index annuity fits relative to other investment types fixed index annuity pros and cons

To be fair when sorting out the advantages and disadvantages of an indexed annuity, it is important to remember that these are insurance products so you should not expect equity-like returns. 

Since indexed annuities are a type of fixed annuity they protect your money from a potential stock market crash. This makes CDs and fixed annuities the indexed annuities alternatives.

How Do Indexed Annuities Work?

Index annuities earn interest-based, in part, on the positive performance of an external stock market index, such as the S&P 500®. Interest is credited to an index annuity on each contract anniversary and is guaranteed to never be less than zero percent. 

Stock Market Indexes available in an indexed annuity

Annuity CompanyAM Best RatingStock Market Index Page
Sentinel Security LifeB++Goldman Sachs Aging of America Dynamic Balance Index (Ticker: SOLAOA)
AIGAS&P 500 (Ticker: SPX)
AIGAAQR DynamiQ Index
AIGAMerrill Lynch Strategic Balanced Index (MLSB)
AIGARussell 2000 Small Cap Market Index .RUT
AIGAMSCI EAFE – Non U.S. and Canada Index EAFE
Allianz LifeA+S&P 500 (Ticker: SPX)
AllianzA+Nasdaq 100 Index
AllianzA+Blackrock iBLD Claria Index (IBLDCLRA)
AllianzA+PIMCO Tactical Balanced Index
AllianzA+Bloomberg US Dynamic Balance Index II
American EquityA-S&P 500 Daily Risk Control 2 8% Index
American EquityA-Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA)
American EquityA-S&P 500 Dividends Aristocrats Index
American EquityA-S&P 500 (Ticker: SPX)
AtheneAAiPex Performance Index
AtheneAS&P 500 Daily Risk Control 2 8% Index
AtheneANASDAQ Fast Convergence Index BOFANFCC
AtheneABNPMAD5 Index
AtheneAS&P 500 Daily Risk Control 5% Index
EquiTrustB++Barclays Focus50 Index (BXIIF50E)
Fidelity & GuarantyA-S&P 500 (Ticker: SPX)
Fidelity & GuarantyA-iShares Real Estate ETF
Fidelity & GuarantyA-Balanced Asset 10 Index
Fidelity & Guaranty A-iShares Core S&P 500 ETF
Fidelity & Guaranty A-Balanced Asset 10 Index. Ticker: CIBQB10E
Fidelity & Guaranty A-Barclays Trailblazer Sector 5 Index (ticker BXIITBZ5)
Global AtlanticAPIMCO Balanced Index PIMBAL
Global AtlanticAMSCI EAFE Non U.S. and Canada Stock Index EAFE
Global AtlanticARussell 2000 Small Cap Index .RUT
Global AtlanticABlackrock Diversa Volatility Controlled Index ^IBLDV7E
Global AtlanticAFranklin U.S. Equity Index FTUSLX
Great AmericanAS&P 500 Daily Risk Control 10% Index
Great American AIShares U.S. Real Estate ETF 1YR
Great AmericanAS&P 500 U.S. Retiree Spending Index
Lincoln Financial A+Fidelity AIM Dividend Index
Lincoln Financial A+S&P 500 Daily Risk Control Index 5%
NationwideA+S&P 500 Daily Risk Control 5% Index
NationwideA+S&P 500
NationwideA+AB Growth and Value Balanced Index
North AmericanA+S&P 500 Low Volatility Daily Risk Control 5%
North AmericanA+S&P MARC 5% ER
North AmericanA+Fidelity Multifactor Yield Index 5% ER
North AmericanA+S&P 500 (Ticker: SPX)
North American A+NASDAQ 100 Index
Oxford LifeA-S&P 500 Index
Oxford LifeA-2 Year Citi Flexible Allocation Index CIISFM6E
PrincipalA+S&P 500 Index SPX
Reliance StandardA+S&P 500 Index
SILAC InsuranceB+Credit Suisse RavenPack
The StanThe StandarddardA+S&P 500 Index SPX

At each annual contract anniversary, the performance of the specified market index is measured. If the index performs (increases in value) the index annuity is automatically credited interest and earns zero percent interest in years that the index goes down.  

There are a couple of different index annuity crediting methods but Annual Point to Point is by far the most common so for time’s sake that’s the one we’ll focus on here.

Fixed index annuity rates & crediting method cartoon illustration

Recent Annuity Articles

Fixed Index Annuity vs Variable Annuity

The line graph below compares the sales of variable annuities (VA) and fixed index annuities (FIA) in the United States from 2006 to 2020. Variable annuities are represented by the blue line while the red line represents indexed annuity sales.

Fixed index annuity and variable annuity from 2006 to 2020

As you can see, variable annuities have decreased in popularity significantly while fixed index annuities are becoming increasingly popular. This is partly because variable annuities have more fees than any other annuity type. 

Variable annuity sales have decreased from approximately $185 Billion in 2006 to ~$100 Billion in 2020. Equity indexed annuities increased from ~$75 Billion to ~$120 Billion in sales.

2016 marked the first year that individual fixed index annuity sales surpassed variable annuity sales in the United States. This is due in large part to the high cost and fees associated with variable annuities vs. low or no fees of an index annuity.

Typical Variable Annuity Product Fees

  1. M&E (mortality and expense) – average around .50%
  2. Sub-Account Fees – average 1.00%
  3. Optional Rider Fees (annuity income rider or death benefit rider) – Average 1.00% each

If you are considering purchasing a variable annuity you will find the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) Variable Annuities: What You Should Know investor tips.

FINRA Investor Alert

For a thorough breakdown of Fixed Index Annuity advantages and disadvantages we suggest reading FINRA’s Investor Alert: Equity Index Annuities: A Complex Choice.

Pros and Cons of a Fixed Index Annuity

Advantages of a Fixed Index Annuity

  • Index annuity account balances are “locked-in” annually.
  • May provide a better rate of return than other investments with principal protection.
  • Annuity investors are able to grow their retirement savings tax-deferred.
  • An index annuity yields a better rate of return when the stock market performs.
  • Optional lifetime annuity income riders are available on many index annuity products.
  • Backed by state-regulated insurance companies with strong financial ratings.
  • You can make unlimited contributions; unlike an IRA or 401(k).

Fixed Index Annuity Disadvantages

  • 10% IRS Penalty Applies to Index Annuity Withdrawals Prior to 59 1/2
  • Fixed Index Annuity gains are taxed as ordinary income, not the lower capital gains tax rate like many other investments.
  • Some of the optional annuity income riders come with annuity fees charged as a percent of your account annually.
  • Indexed annuities come with charge a fee on withdrawals above the free withdrawal amount (so do many annuity contracts).
  • The interest you can earn in an Index Annuity is limited by an index annuity crediting method so there is less upside potential than riskier investment options.
  • The vast variety of Index Annuity products and features can be confusing and at times seem overwhelming.
  • Annuity Companies can your annuity’s interest crediting rates at each contract anniversary.

Is an Index Annuity Right for You?

There are multiple annuity products so I wanted to wrap up my fixed index annuity pros and cons guide with some helpful tips on how to decide if a fixed index annuity may be a good investment for you.

 An Index Annuity may be right for you if…

    • You have a retirement plan in place with equity components, but want to diversify with low-risk annuities.
    • You want a generate a steady stream of guaranteed annuity income.
    • You want the chance to earn more interest than you would if you bought another type of fixed annuity product. 
    • You have maxed out your 401(k) and traditional IRA’s and want to contribute more to tax-deferred investments.
    • You are approaching or already retired and need to minimize the sequence of returns risk.
An Index Annuity may not be right for you if…
    • You are very comfortable with risk and fluctuations in your portfolio balance
    • You have already incorporated enough fixed income solutions that hedge against market volatility into your retirement portfolio.
    • You anticipate you may need to the cash in your annuity before the full term of the contract or before you reach age 59 1/2. 
    • You are behind on your retirement savings and really need to invest in riskier assets in an attempt to make up for lost time with higher gains.

Frequently Asked Index Annuity Questions

You can not lose money in a fixed index annuity even if the stock market crashes because your money is not invested directly in the stock market. An index annuity earns interest based on the performance of a stock market index but zero percent is the worst your annuity can do in any given year.

Fixed index annuities are a good retirement savings vehicle for a conservative investor who wants to keep their principal protected but also would like a chance to earn more interest than a fixed annuity or CD will guarantee.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest


Buy An Annuity Online

Complete your annuity application electronically.

Annuity Rates

Compare live annuity rates from more than 50 annuity companies

Annuity Quotes

Get a fixed, income or fixed index annuity quote online.

Life Insurance Quotes

Get instant life insurance quotes online.

Annuity Calculators

Access more than 20 calculators.

Annuity Reviews

Make informed buying decisions.

Free Annuity Quote

Receive a personalized annuity quote within 4 business hours.