Skip to content

Annuity Taxes

What Is Cost Basis in an Annuity?

Cost basis in an annuity is the after-tax money you paid into the contract. That money comes back to you tax-free, and only the growth above it is taxed as ordinary income.[1]

Below: how to figure your basis, when it comes back to you, and what happens to it at death or in a 1035 exchange.

What Is Cost Basis in an Annuity?

Cost basis in an annuity is the IRS’s “investment in the contract”: the premiums you paid with money that was already taxed. Account value minus cost basis equals your taxable gain.

  • Non-qualified annuity (funded with savings, a CD or a brokerage account): basis = every premium you paid. Deposit $200,000 and your basis is $200,000.
  • Qualified annuity (an IRA or 401(k) rollover): basis is usually $0, because the money went in pre-tax. Every dollar out is taxable.
  • The exception: after-tax 401(k) contributions and non-deductible IRA contributions tracked on IRS Form 8606 do count as basis.[2]

Example: Sandra puts $200,000 of savings into a 7-year MYGA. It grows to $290,000. Her basis is $200,000, so only the $90,000 gain is taxable.

How Is Cost Basis Taxed When You Withdraw?

Partial withdrawals from a non-qualified deferred annuity come out gain first, under the IRS “last in, first out” (LIFO) rule. You reach your tax-free basis only after every dollar of gain is gone.[1]

Example: David has a $100,000 basis and a $135,000 account value, so $35,000 of gain.

  • He takes $25,000: all $25,000 is taxable gain. His basis stays at $100,000.
  • He takes $40,000 instead: the first $35,000 is taxable, and the last $5,000 is a tax-free return of basis.
  • Under age 59½: the taxable part usually carries a 10% IRS penalty on top of income tax. See the 59½ rule.

To run your own numbers, use the annuity tax calculator. Owning several smaller contracts can change the math, as shown in how annuity withdrawals are taxed.

How Much of My Annuity Income Is Taxable?

When you annuitize (turn the contract into guaranteed payments), LIFO no longer applies. The IRS uses the exclusion ratio to spread your basis evenly across the payments you are expected to receive.[1]

Formula: exclusion ratio = cost basis ÷ expected total payments.

Example: Margaret annuitizes with a $120,000 basis and $200,000 in expected payments, so 60% of each check is tax-free.

  • Each $1,100 monthly check: $660 tax-free, $440 taxable.
  • Once she recovers the full $120,000: every later payment is fully taxable.
  • If she dies first: the unrecovered basis can be deducted on her final tax return.

Want to see what a payout would look like? Compare single premium immediate annuity income.

Do Annuities Get a Stepped-Up Cost Basis?

No. Annuities do not get a step-up in basis at death the way stocks and real estate do. Your beneficiary inherits your original basis and owes ordinary income tax on all the gain.

Example: Robert paid $100,000 for an annuity worth $170,000 when he died. His daughter owes tax on the $70,000 gain, which is $15,400 in federal tax at a 22% bracket.

Your payout choices change when that tax is due. See how annuity beneficiaries are taxed.

What Happens to Cost Basis in a 1035 Exchange?

Your basis and your gain both carry over unchanged to the new contract. A 1035 exchange defers the tax on the gain; it does not erase it.

The new carrier may not have your original purchase records. Keep the old application, statements and exchange paperwork, because tracking basis is your job, not the insurer’s.

What Changes Your Cost Basis?

Event Effect on cost basis
New after-tax premium Increases basis by the amount paid
Withdrawal smaller than the gain No change (gain comes out first)
Withdrawal larger than the gain Reduces basis by the excess
Annuitized payments Basis is recovered a little with each payment
1035 exchange Basis and gain carry over
Owner’s death No step-up; beneficiary keeps your basis

How Do I Find My Annuity’s Cost Basis?

  1. Annual statement. Most carriers list “investment in the contract” or “cost basis” next to the account value.
  2. Form 1099-R. Box 1 is the gross distribution and Box 2a is the taxable amount. The difference is basis that came back tax-free.[3]
  3. Form 8606. For IRA annuities with non-deductible contributions, this is your official record of after-tax basis.
  4. Ask the carrier in writing. Before a large withdrawal, surrender or 1035 exchange, request a cost basis letter.

Cashing out early? Check surrender charges first, since they cut what you receive.

Know Your Basis Before You Buy

We compare fixed annuity rates from 90+ top annuity companies and show you the after-tax picture before you commit.

Keep your purchase records, because the cost basis in an annuity is what decides how much of every dollar you take out is taxed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is cost basis the same as my account value?

No. Account value is what the contract is worth today. Cost basis is only the after-tax money you put in, and the difference between the two is your taxable gain.

What is my cost basis if I rolled over a 401(k)?

Usually $0, because pre-tax contributions were never taxed. Any after-tax contributions you made to the 401(k) do count as basis, so ask the plan administrator before you roll it over.

Can I increase my cost basis?

Yes, by adding after-tax premium. Each deposit raises your basis by that amount. Most MYGAs are single-premium contracts that do not accept new money, while some fixed index annuities allow deposits in the first year or two.

How does the IRS verify cost basis?

The carrier reports each distribution on Form 1099-R, with the gross amount in Box 1 and the taxable amount in Box 2a. If the carrier cannot determine the taxable amount, it is your job to prove your basis with purchase records or Form 8606.

Do RMDs from an IRA annuity affect cost basis?

Usually not, because a traditional IRA annuity typically has no basis. RMDs are fully taxable unless you made non-deductible contributions tracked on Form 8606.

Sources & References

Editorial Policy: Our editorial team independently reviews and rates annuity products. My Annuity Store earns a commission from the insurance company if you purchase an annuity through our platform. There is no fee to you. This content is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Annuity products vary by state and carrier.

Related Articles

Keep exploring topics related to this guide.

Mas 100000 annuity monthly income featured 1

Annuities 101

How Much Does a $100,000 Annuity Pay Per Month?

How much a $100,000 annuity pays per month depends on your age, the annuity type, and when income starts. See current payouts and how to compare quotes.

Updated
Mas premium tax by state

Annuities 101

Annuity State Premium Tax (2026): Full Rate Chart

Only 7 states and Puerto Rico charge an annuity premium tax (0.08% to 3.5%). See the full 50-state chart, what it costs, and how to avoid it. Updated 2026.

Updated
2026 EDITION
The Plain-English Guide to Deferred Annuities.
myannuitystore.com
Free download

Get the 2026 Buyer’s Guide, free.

A plain-English walkthrough: the four product types, fees, riders, your rights, and the questions to ask before you sign. No sales pressure.

Instant access · No spam · We never sell your information.

You’re in. Here’s your guide.

Your download should start automatically. If it doesn’t, use the button below. We’ve also added you to our newsletter for rate updates and new guides.

Download the Guide (PDF) ↓
Get Free Quote Call Now