855-583-1104

Top 20 Best Bonus Annuity Rates for May 2026

Jason Caudill, MBA
Updated May 1, 2026 | 4 min read

What is a Bonus Annuity?

Bonus annuities are a type of Fixed or Fixed Index Annuity that pay an upfront premium bonus. The bonus is paid as a percent of your original purchase premium. A rule of thumb is longer annuity contracts usually pay a higher bonus.

If you are looking for an accumulation product that pays a guaranteed interest rate for the entire annuity contract you may want to look at fixed annuity rates instead.

For example, if you purchase a bonus annuity with a 5% premium bonus for $100,000 you would receive a $5,000 bonus – making your annuity’s account value $105,000.

Annuity Providers Offering Bonus Annuities

Carrier/Product NameAM BestMax AgeMinimumPremium BonusProduct FeeAny Annual P-to-P CapTerm
ATHENE IA - Athene Performance Elite® 15 Plus MVA ROP FEEA+7310,00027.00-29.000.957.0015 yrs
NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY - Charter Plus 14 MVA High BandA+7575,00017.00-29.006.5014 yrs
NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY - Charter Plus 14 MVA Low BandA+7520,00013.00-25.006.5014 yrs
HEARTLAND NATIONAL - Secure Retirement 10 Max MVAB++805,00010.00-25.006.0010 yrs
MIDLAND NATIONAL LIFE - IndexBuilder 14 OABR MVA High BandA+7575,00017.00-24.006.2514 yrs
AMERICAN LIFE - American Select 10 Bonus Plus MVA FEEB++8520,00020.00-23.000.806.00 (0.00),6.0010 yrs
NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY - Charter Plus 10 MVA High BandA+7975,00014.00-23.006.0010 yrs
NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY - Charter Plus 10 (State Variations) High BandA+7975,00014.00-23.005.7510 yrs
MIDLAND NATIONAL LIFE - IndexBuilder 10 OABR MVA High BandA+7975,00016.00-23.006.0010 yrs
MIDLAND NATIONAL LIFE - IndexBuilder 10 State Variations OABR MVA High BandA+7975,00016.00-23.005.7510 yrs
AXONIC INSURANCE - Trailhead 10 PLUS Enhanced MVA FEE Low BandA-8920,00023.000.956.5010 yrs
AXONIC INSURANCE - Trailhead 10 PLUS Enhanced MVA FEE High BandA-89100,00023.000.956.7510 yrs
IBEXIS - WealthDefender Bonus Plus 10 MVA FEE Low BandA-7825,00019.50-22.500.855.0010 yrs
IBEXIS - WealthDefender Bonus Plus 10 MVA FEE High BandA-78100,00019.50-22.500.856.0010 yrs
ATHENE IA - Athene Performance Elite 10 Plus MVA ROP FEEA+7810,00018.00-22.000.955.5010 yrs
ATHENE IA - Athene Performance Elite® 15 MVAA+7310,00020.00-22.007.0015 yrs
NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY - Charter Plus 10 CA High BandA+7975,00022.005.7510 yrs
NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY - Secure Horizon Plus MVAA+7925,00022.0010 yrs
AMERICAN EQUITY INVESTMENT LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY - AssetShield Bonus 10 MVAA805,00014.00-21.005.5010 yrs
NASSAU LIFE AND ANNUITY COMPANY - Nassau Bonus Annuity Plus Group A MVA ROP FEEB++8015,00021.000.956.25 (0.00),6.2510 yrs

Back to Fixed Index Annuity Rates

Things to Consider When Buying Bonus Annuities

Available Indexes: The stock market indexes are available in the index annuity. We have a list of available stock market indexes available at each insurance carrier for simplicity.

Crediting methods (or limiting factors): Index annuity crediting methods are used to determine what interest rate is credited to your account annually. For example, cap rate, spread, or participation rate.

Insurer Rating: Financial Ratings are very important because they are an indicator of an insurance company’s ability to fulfill its obligations to its policyholders.

Investment Term: Terms range from 3 years to 10 years. During that period of time, you’ll receive a guaranteed rate but will have limited access to your funds. Usually, the longer the term the higher the yield but that isn’t the case in today’s rate environment.

Liquidity: You’ll notice a column for liquidity at our annuity marketplace; there will either be 10% or interest-only listed. This is the annual free withdrawal amount you can take from your annuity contract each year without a surrender penalty.

While a bonus annuity can be a great option in the right circumstances, there are also times when it is probably not the best solution. Bonus annuities typically have a longer surrender period than other fixed indexed annuities. For the most part, to get a bonus annuity, you must be willing to commit to at least a 7-year contract.

Another point worth noting is that the crediting component rates on bonus annuities are typically lower than those of an annuity without a bonus. For example, an index annuity without a bonus may have an annual cap of 5%, meaning your account is credited up to 5% annually based on the performance of the market index you’ve selected. A bonus annuity of the same quality and duration may be subject to a 4% cap.

So, in essence, you are getting extra interest upfront in exchange for earning potential in the future. This is generally not worth it if your primary objective is accumulation. However, if your objective is to use this portion of your retirement savings for guaranteed lifetime income, a bonus annuity may make sense.

Fixed Index Annuities have a reputation for being complicated, when in fact they are very simple compared to many other investment options. If you are considering a fixed index annuity, we suggest reading FINRA’s “The Complicated Risks and Rewards of Indexed Annuities.”

Bonus Annuities Pros and Cons

When shopping for a bonus annuity, it is important to weigh the pros and cons.

Bonus Annuity Pros

  • Sometimes people find themselves in an investment product that no longer meets their risk tolerance, but there is a penalty to surrender the contract. When that is the case, bonus annuities can help offset the surrender charge and help you come out whole.
  • If you are purchasing an annuity with an income rider and plan to take income in the first few years, a bonus can help boost your lifetime income payments.

Bonus Annuity Cons

  • Bonus annuities usually have long surrender charges.
  • The bonus usually has a vesting schedule, meaning if you get out of the annuity, some of your bonus will be recaptured.
  • Bonus annuities usually have lower caps or interest rates, limiting your future income potential.

Related Pages

Keep going with the most helpful next steps–compare options, understand costs, and see how buying online works.

 

Best Fixed Annuity Companies

A ranked shortlist for shoppers who value guarantees and simple terms.

Read more

Comparison

 

 

How to Buy an Annuity (Step-by-Step)

Exactly what to expect from quote to application.

  • What info you’ll need (age, state, premium, goals)
  • Timeline + underwriting “gotchas”
  • Delivery requirements + funding methods

Read more

Guide

 

 

How Much Does a $500,000 Pay Per Month?

Learn how much a $500K annuity pays per month and which type would pay you the most.

Read more

Must-read

 

 

Today’s Fixed Annuity Rates

Compare fixed annuity rates for more than 500 products; updated live every 30 minutes.

Read more

Compare

Get Today's Best Annuity Rates
Compare 90+ top annuity companies. Rates up to 6.50%. No obligation.
Disclaimer: This content is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Annuity products vary by state and carrier. Always consult a licensed financial professional before making any financial decisions. My Annuity Store is an independent marketplace and does not provide investment advice.
Live Data · Updated Daily

Featured Retirement Savings Products for May 5, 2026

3-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Farmers Life Insurance Company Best Rate
Farmers Safeguard Plus 3
Term: 3 yr Min: $10,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best B++
5.65% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 3 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 3 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
5.60% Guaranteed APY
Revol One Financial
DirectGrowth 3
Term: 3 yr Min: $25,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best B++
5.55% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: May 5, 2026, 6:11 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

5-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
American Gulf Best Rate
Anchor MYGA 5
Term: 5 yr Min: $10,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best B++
6.30% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 5 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.30% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 5 CA (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.20% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: May 5, 2026, 6:11 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

7-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Knighthead Life Best Rate
Staysail 7 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 7 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.50% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 7 CA (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 7 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.40% Guaranteed APY
American Gulf
Anchor MYGA 7
Term: 7 yr Min: $10,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best B++
6.30% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: May 5, 2026, 6:11 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

5-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Athene IA Best Rate
Athene Max Rate 5
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: Interest Only AM Best A+
5.20% Guaranteed APY
Nationwide Life Insurance Company
Secure Growth 5 MVA
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 10% AM Best A+
5.20% Guaranteed APY
Athene IA
Athene Max Rate 5 (state specific)
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: Interest Only AM Best A+
5.15% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: May 5, 2026, 6:11 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

Rates sourced from AnnuityRateWatch. A-rated carriers (AM Best A− or better) only. Not a solicitation. Rates vary by state and deposit size. Verify current rates before purchasing.

Jason Caudill, MBA
Written by
Jason Caudill, MBA

Jason Caudill, MBA is the founder of My Annuity Store and has spent over 15 years helping clients protect retirement savings with annuities from top annuity companies. He is an independent licensed insurance agent, not affiliated with any single carrier, which means you always get unbiased guidance.

Read more from Jason →
Get Free Quote Call Now