855-583-1104

My Annuity Store Reviews

Jason Caudill, MBA
Updated June 27, 2026 | 2 min read

The short version: My Annuity Store is a BBB-accredited independent annuity marketplace founded in 2020, with an A+ Better Business Bureau rating and more than $1 billion in annuities placed for clients. The verified client reviews below come straight from our Better Business Bureau profile.

4.9
★★★★★
44 verified client reviews
Sourced from BBB · verify on BBB
Read All Reviews →

What our clients say

These are real, verified reviews from people we have helped buy an annuity. We did not write them and we cannot edit them. They come directly from our Better Business Bureau profile.

4.9
★★★★★
44 verified client reviews
Sourced from BBB · verify on BBB
Read All Reviews →
★★★★★ BBB
Dennis Benner
Lehigh County, PA · June 2026

We have been using this company for several years. They are knowledgeable on all facets of their annuity products. Their customer service is outstanding. I highly recommend them for annuity purchases.

★★★★★ BBB
John Fiebiger
Raleigh, NC · February 0026

I have worked with Kiara for over a year, and she has been outstanding. She is always prompt, helpful, informative and kind. Kiara fully understands her products and has always looked out for my best interests. I highly recommend speaking with Kiara for help with your financial support.

★★★★★ BBB
Carl B.
Las Vegas, NV · April 2026

I appreciated Ms. Caudill's speedy service and her honesty. I rate My Annuity Store 5 out of 5.

★★★★★ BBB
E. Clark
Stuart, FL · April 2026

Kiara has helped me so much.....knowledgable, patient, and kind. Always follows up with me and is a true professional.

★★★★★ BBB
Joseph B.
Savannah, GA · May 2026

Very professional and efficient service. My interactions and follow through with My Annuity Store will lead me to consider further Annuity purchases with them.

★★★★★ BBB
Lisa B.
Novato, CA · May 2026

The Annuity Store.com provided excellent service from start to finish. The team was knowledgeable, responsive, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I highly recommend them and would definitely use them again for any future annuity needs.

★★★★★ BBB
Dell Y.
Bella Vista, AR · May 2026

Kiara was very professional and helpful. She had all the answers and was easy to work with. I would use her again.

★★★★★ BBB
Kenneth H.
Dracut, MA · May 2026

Very satisfied with buying a MYGA through My Annuity Store. I was able to select the highest rate that fits my circumstances with Kiara walking me through the process. I will definitely use the My Annuity Store for my fixed income MYGA needs.

★★★★★ BBB
Pamela T.
West Bloomfield, MI · May 2026

My Annuity Store has been great to work with - knowledgeable, attentive service, with no pressure. Highly recommended!

★★★★★ BBB
Fred B.
Madison, WI · May 2026

The process in working with Kiara went very smoothly, as she helped me choose the appropriate insurance companies, compute the appropriate amounts considering state coverages, and was efficient in the process of completing the applications and related follow up for the wire transfers and issuance of policies. Was very happy with working with Kiara.

★★★★★ BBB
Derek S.
January 2026

If you are looking for a place to purchase an annuity with no pressure to make the purchase, then My Annuity Store is the place. They answered all my questions and never asked how much are you going to deposit. Jason and Kiara are very genuine people! I am very pleased with the great communication along the way. I was given updates as my application proceeded to issue. You can buy with confidence at My Annuity Store!

★★★★★ BBB
Andrew S.
March 2012

Working by the book. Easy to work with. Kiara is doing her job!

About these reviews. All reviews are real client testimonials sourced from our verified BBB profile (verify here). Reviews describe client experiences with MyAnnuityStore as a brokerage and are not testimonials about any specific annuity product. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Annuity recommendations depend on individual financial circumstances; please contact us for guidance specific to your situation.

Why clients choose My Annuity Store

We are an independent agency, not the captive sales arm of any one insurer. That means we shop 90+ insurance companies on your behalf and compare live rates side by side, instead of steering you toward a single product. Our producers are in-house, we never resell your information, and there is no cost to work with us.

How we collect reviews

Every review on this page is collected and verified by the Better Business Bureau. They are not solicited with incentives or filtered for tone. We think the most useful thing we can show a prospective client is the unedited experience of the people who came before them. If you have worked with us, you can leave your own review on our BBB profile.

Ready to see what we can do for you? Request a free annuity quote or contact our team. Founder Jason Caudill and our licensed producers are here to help, with no pressure and no obligation.

Get Today's Best Annuity Rates

Compare 90+ top annuity companies. Rates up to 6.50%. No obligation.

Disclaimer: This content is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Annuity products vary by state and carrier. Always consult a licensed financial professional before making any financial decisions. My Annuity Store is an independent marketplace and does not provide investment advice.
Live Data · Updated Daily

Featured Retirement Savings Products for July 16, 2026

3-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Knighthead Life Best Rate
Staysail 3 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 3 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
5.80% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 3 CA (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 3 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
5.70% Guaranteed APY
Farmers Life Insurance Company
Farmers Safeguard Plus 3
Term: 3 yr Min: $10,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best B++
5.65% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: July 16, 2026, 9:50 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

5-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Knighthead Life Best Rate
Staysail 5 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.45% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 5 CA (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.35% Guaranteed APY
American Gulf
Anchor MYGA 5
Term: 5 yr Min: $10,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best B++
6.00% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: July 16, 2026, 9:50 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

7-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Knighthead Life Best Rate
Staysail 7 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 7 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.80% Guaranteed APY
Knighthead Life
Staysail 7 CA (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 7 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 0% AM Best A-
6.70% Guaranteed APY
Ibexis
MYGA Plus 7 (Simple Interest) SI
Term: 7 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 10% AM Best A-
6.15% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: July 16, 2026, 9:50 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

5-Year MYGA Rates Top 3 carriers
Nationwide Life Insurance Company Best Rate
Secure Growth 5 MVA
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: 10% AM Best A+
5.40% Guaranteed APY
North American Company
NAC Guarantee Plus 5
Term: 5 yr Min: $100,000 Withdrawal: Interest Only AM Best A+
5.35% Guaranteed APY
Protective Life
Secure Saver 5
Term: 5 yr Min: $75,000 Withdrawal: 10% AM Best A+
5.35% Guaranteed APY

Rates updated: July 16, 2026, 9:50 am ET · Source: AnnuityRateWatch. Rates shown are for informational purposes only and subject to change without notice. Products marked SI use simple interest, effective compound yield is lower than the stated rate. Minimum premiums shown are for non-qualified (after-tax) funds. Always verify current rates with a licensed annuity professional before purchasing.

Rates sourced from AnnuityRateWatch. Not a solicitation. Rates vary by state and deposit size. Verify current rates before purchasing.

Jason Caudill, MBA
Written by
Jason Caudill, MBA

Jason Caudill, MBA is the founder of My Annuity Store and has spent over 20 years helping clients protect retirement savings with annuities from top annuity companies. He is an independent licensed insurance agent, not affiliated with any single carrier, which means you always get unbiased guidance.

Read more from Jason →
2026 EDITION
The Plain-English Guide to Deferred Annuities.
myannuitystore.com
Free download

Get the 2026 Buyer’s Guide — free.

A plain-English walkthrough: the four product types, fees, riders, your rights, and the questions to ask before you sign. No sales pressure.

Instant access · No spam · We never sell your information.

You’re in — here’s your guide.

Your download should start automatically. If it doesn’t, use the button below. We’ve also added you to our newsletter for rate updates and new guides.

Download the Guide (PDF) ↓
Get Free Quote Call Now